The RTO Show: "Let's talk Rent to Own"

Michael Bennett on Leadership, Rent to Own Growth, and the Future of the RTO Industry

• Pete Shau • Season 7 • Episode 17

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 1:03:37

Send us Fan Mail

What does it take to build a decades long leadership career in the rent to own industry while navigating economic downturns, company transitions, and industry evolution?

In this special Legends episode of The RTO Show, Pete Shau sits down with Michael Bennett, CEO of Buddy’s Home Furnishings and former three time APRO president, to explore the people first leadership philosophy that shaped his career and helped influence the future of rent to own. 

Michael shares stories from Rent A Center, RentWay, Aaron’s, and Buddy’s Home Furnishings while discussing servant leadership, rent to own operations, collections strategies, franchise growth, virtual rent to own, customer service, and the long term future of the RTO industry. Listeners will learn how leadership, adaptability, and relationship building continue to shape one of the most resilient sectors in retail finance and consumer access. 


What You’ll Learn

  • How Michael Bennett built a leadership career across multiple major rent to own companies including Rent A Center, RentWay, Aaron’s, and Buddy’s Home Furnishings
  • Why servant leadership and people first culture remain critical for long term success in rent to own operations
  • How collections, customer relationships, and accountability helped shape Michael’s management philosophy
  • What the future of virtual rent to own, e commerce, and digital customer acquisition could mean for the RTO industry
  • Why setbacks, economic downturns, and career pivots often become the foundation for stronger leadership


Episode Highlights:

  • 02:18 – Michael Bennett reflects on serving three terms as APRO president and helping guide the rent to own industry through major transitions
  • 06:38 – How hustling as a kid and building early businesses shaped Michael’s entrepreneurial mindset
  • 11:15 – Why Michael joined Rent A Center in 1993 and started his career working on a delivery truck
  • 15:20 – The leadership and operational systems Michael learned during the rapid growth years at Rent A Center
  • 21:05 – What happened during Michael’s transition to RentWay and the lessons learned from rebuilding struggling regions
  • 28:30 – How Aaron’s franchise operations grew average store revenue from $40,000 to more than $111,000 per store
  • 34:05 – A leadership lesson about empowering frontline employees and why “titles don’t matter, people do”
  • 51:00 – Michael’s prediction for the future of rent to own, virtual RTO, customer service, and industry consolidation
  • 56:14 – The leadership books and frameworks Michael recommends for developing future RTO leaders


Meet the Guest:

Michael Bennett is the CEO of Buddy’s Home Furnishings and a former three time president of APRO, the Association of Progressive Rental Organizations. With more than 30 years of experience in the rent to own industry, Michael has held leadership roles at Rent A Center, RentWay, Aaron’s, and Buddy’s while helping shape operational strategy, franchise growth, and industry advocacy. 


Tools, Frameworks, or Strategies Mentioned:

  • Servant leadership principles
  • Welcome, Wanted, Important customer culture
  • Guerrilla marketing strategies for rent to own
  • Virtual rent to own and e commerce growth models
  • Customer collections and relationship management systems
  • Franchise operations scaling strategies
  • The “Law of the Lid” leadership framework
  • APRO industry advocacy and consumer access initiatives
  • Leadership development through Failure Forward and The 21 Irrefutable Laws of Leadership


Closing Insight:

“Titles don’t matter. People matter.”

Michael Bennett’s story is a reminder that the future of rent to own will always depend on leadership, adaptability, customer relationships, and investing in people at every level of the business.

Support the show

Join The RTO Newsletter: https://bit.ly/RTOPODnewsletter

Subscribe on Apple: https://apple.co/4wpbUqF

Subscribe on Spotify: https://bit.ly/RTOPODspotify

Learn More About Sponsorship: https://bit.ly/RTOPODsponsor

People on this episode