The RTO Show: "Let's talk Rent to Own"

Building Customer Loyalty: From First Hello to Final Payment with Jason Winters

Pete Shau Season 5 Episode 17

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 1:02:19

Send us Fan Mail

Why are so many rent to own customers paying off agreements and never coming back?

In this episode of The RTO Show, Pete Shau and Jason Winters break down the real drivers behind payout conversion, customer retention, and long term rent to own loyalty.

This conversation explores rent to own sales strategy, PIF conversion tactics, EPO conversion rates, customer experience management, and operational systems that help stores keep customers engaged beyond the end of an agreement. From delivery service and showroom presentation to loyalty programs and referral marketing, this episode gives RTO operators practical ways to improve conversion rates and grow recurring revenue.

What You’ll Learn:

  • Why payout conversion starts on day one of the customer experience and not at the end of the agreement
  • How rent to own stores can improve PIF and EPO conversion rates through service, follow up, and operational consistency
  • The role customer loyalty programs, referral incentives, and relationship marketing play in customer retention
  • How product bundling, upselling, and wishlist selling create stronger rent to own sales opportunities
  • Why delivery experience, store presentation, and service recovery directly impact repeat business and customer lifetime value
  • How successful rent to own stores create systems that increase customer trust, ownership rates, and long term retention

Episode Highlights:

  • 02:21 – Why rent to own conversion rates are struggling in today’s economy
  • 04:14 – The 90 day process for improving payout conversions before agreements end
  • 05:00 – How delivery experience shapes customer loyalty and repeat business
  • 10:30 – Why top performing stores focus on ownership and customer relationships
  • 14:16 – The importance of staying connected during the final 90 days of an agreement
  • 20:36 – How loyalty programs and customer rewards could reshape the RTO industry
  • 27:24 – Why high payout rates are one of the strongest indicators of a successful rent to own store
  • 30:17 – How bundling products and building room packages improves sales conversions
  • 35:41 – The hidden operational problems that destroy customer retention and referrals
  • 44:03 – Why great service recovery matters more than sales tricks at the end of the agreement
  • 56:12 – The powerful customer service lesson behind a simple pair of white gloves

Meet the Guest:

Jason Winters brings years of rent to own operational experience and shares frontline insights on customer service, payout conversions, delivery systems, and sales performance.

Tools, Frameworks, or Strategies Mentioned:

  • PIF conversion strategy
  • EPO conversion process
  • 90 day customer retention workflow
  • Wishlist selling techniques
  • Product bundling and package selling
  • Referral based customer acquisition
  • Loyalty and rewards program concepts
  • Customer service recovery systems
  • Store presentation and merchandising strategy
  • Delivery experience optimization
  • Rent to own customer lifecycle management
  • Retention focused operational processes

Closing Insight:

Customers already want the products. The real question is whether they want to keep doing business with you.

The stores with the strongest payout conversion rates are usually the stores that create trust, solve problems quickly, and deliver a customer experience worth coming back for. In rent to own, relationships still matter.

Support the show

Join The RTO Newsletter: https://bit.ly/RTOPODnewsletter

Subscribe on Apple: https://apple.co/4wpbUqF

Subscribe on Spotify: https://bit.ly/RTOPODspotify

Learn More About Sponsorship: https://bit.ly/RTOPODsponsor

People on this episode